I recently wrapped up a leadership development program with a group of managers, and our final session focused on a topic that makes almost everyone uncomfortable: conflict.
I started with a simple question: Is conflict at work good or bad?
The overwhelming response? It depends. And they’re right. Conflict can destroy a team. But the absence of conflict can be just as destructive. In fact, I’d argue that one of the biggest threats to a scaling company isn’t too much conflict. It’s too little.
The Problem With Being Nice
Patrick Lencioni’s The Five Dysfunctions of a Team identifies fear of conflict as the second dysfunction, right after absence of trust.
When teams don’t trust each other enough to disagree openly, they create what Lencioni calls artificial harmony.
Everyone nods along in the meeting. Nobody raises the obvious concern. The decision gets made.
Then the real conversations happen afterward… In Slack messages. In one-on-ones. Over drinks.
And suddenly the leader is wondering why nobody is executing on a decision everyone supposedly agreed to.
Here’s the thing: Agreement isn’t the same as commitment.
People need to feel heard before they can genuinely commit to a decision, even one they disagree with.
And that requires conflict.
Say the Last 10%
One of my favorite leadership rituals comes from a founder who ends important discussions with a simple request:
“Say the last 10%.”
The premise is that most people share about 90% of what they’re thinking in a meeting.
The remaining 10% is often the most important part.
It’s the concern they don’t want to raise. The disagreement that feels politically risky. The observation that might make someone uncomfortable.
By explicitly inviting people to share that final 10%, the leader makes it safer to say what everyone else might be thinking.
But there’s a catch. You can’t invite the last 10% and then punish someone for sharing it.
Leaders have to demonstrate that disagreement is not only tolerated but valued.
Stop Taking It Offline
One of the most dangerous sentences I hear in the corporate world is…
“Let’s take this offline.”
Sometimes that’s appropriate. But more often, it’s a polite way to escape discomfort.
Someone raises a difficult issue. The room gets tense. The leader senses things are getting uncomfortable and suggests continuing the conversation privately.
Except the conversation often never happens. Or worse, it happens without the people who needed to hear it. Instead, try saying:
“This feels uncomfortable, but I think it’s important. Can we stay with it for a few more minutes?”
Healthy teams don’t avoid discomfort. They learn how to work through it.
One of the coaches in our session offered a phrase I love: intellectual friction.
That’s what we’re really after.
Not personal attacks. Not endless debate. But the productive friction that comes from smart people with different perspectives trying to solve something together.
The Conflict Beneath the Conflict
Of course, not every disagreement is what it appears to be.
There are two broad categories of conflict:
Substantive conflict: We disagree about priorities, resources, goals, or how to get something done.
Emotional conflict: We have different communication styles, personalities, expectations, or ways of relating to one another.
The challenge is that one often masquerades as the other. A disagreement about a missed deadline might actually be about feeling disrespected. A debate over resource allocation might really be about two leaders who don’t trust each other. This is why curiosity matters so much.
Before jumping into problem-solving, ask yourself:
What are we actually disagreeing about?
You can’t solve a problem you haven’t correctly identified.
The Contracts Nobody Signed
One of the most interesting parts of our conversation was about what I call hidden contracts: These are expectations we hold of other people that we’ve never actually communicated.
Maybe you expect colleagues to respond to Slack messages within two hours.
Maybe you believe being five minutes late to a meeting is disrespectful.
Maybe you think a good teammate should proactively offer help when someone is overwhelmed.
Those expectations might feel obvious to you, but they’re not universal.
And when someone violates an expectation they didn’t know existed, we often interpret it as a character flaw.
They’re inconsiderate. They’re unreliable. They don’t care.
When in reality, they may simply be operating under a different set of rules.
You can’t hold someone accountable to a contract they never agreed to.
This is why I love having leaders create personal user manuals that explain how they work best.
How do I prefer to receive feedback? What does it look like when I’m overwhelmed? What’s something I do that might frustrate others, and how should they call me out?
These conversations might feel awkward at first.
But they’re a lot less awkward than the conflict that comes from never having them.
The Real Cost of Avoidance
Toward the end of our session, we talked about what happens when you’ve simply given up on someone.
You know the colleague.
The one who’s difficult to work with. Who never responds. Who always seems to have an excuse.
Eventually, you stop trying.
You work around them. You lower your expectations. You tell yourself it’s not worth the energy.
I’ve been there.
Earlier in my career, I had a colleague I’d essentially written off. I didn’t think our relationship was salvageable, and I’d decided to invest my energy elsewhere.
My CEO challenged me to try again.
I didn’t want to.
But I did. And to my surprise, the relationship improved significantly.
That experience taught me something I’ve carried into my coaching ever since:
Apathy is often just conflict avoidance in disguise.
When we stop caring enough to have the hard conversation, we’ve usually already decided the relationship isn’t worth saving.
And sometimes that’s true.
But I wonder how many relationships, teams, and careers could be transformed if we made one more genuine attempt.
One Thing to Try This Week
At your next leadership team meeting, before closing an important discussion, ask:
“What’s the 10% we haven’t said yet?”
Then be quiet.
Give people time to think.
And when someone finally shares the uncomfortable thing, thank them.
Because the goal isn’t to eliminate conflict.
It’s to create a team where people care enough, and trust each other enough, to disagree.
Winning should be joyful. But that doesn’t mean it should always be comfortable.
